Bach case by era

J
JLivi
Posts: 870
Joined: May 10, 2018

by JLivi »

So I'm looking at various Bach 36's on the internet and don't know much about Bach. I know a lot about king, a little about Conn and nothing about Bach. One thing that I wish I could do was pin point the era the horn is from based on the case (assuming it's original).

Is there a guide to know what bach case design is from what era?

I noticed the corporation horns come with a slick black case with blue velvet interior. And to be honest, I don't even know what years the Corp years were. Any and all info would be greatly appreciated.

And outside of that did the engravings or text on the bells change?
E
elmsandr
Posts: 1373
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by elmsandr »

[quote="JLivi"]So I'm looking at various Bach 36's on the internet and don't know much about Bach. I know a lot about king, a little about Conn and nothing about Bach. One thing that I wish I could do was pin point the era the horn is from based on the case (assuming it's original).

Is there a guide to know what bach case design is from what era?

I noticed the corporation horns come with a slick black case with blue velvet interior. And to be honest, I don't even know what years the Corp years were. Any and all info would be greatly appreciated.

And outside of that did the engravings or text on the bells change?[/quote]
So, first, yes the engravings did change. The reason "Corporation" horns are called that is because it says "Corporation" underneath the signature. There is also the circle R registered trademark logo in the signature. Corp era is Elkhart horns from start (65-ish) through the early 80's (not exactly a hard cutoff date for that).

For cases, there was an evolution and some options as well. There are some early Elkharts with optional square cases that look like later (and earlier) fancy ones. This from a S/N 96xx 50B2 :
<ATTACHMENT filename="Case.jpg" index="2">[attachment=2]Case.jpg</ATTACHMENT>

But most are those French style cases seen here:
<ATTACHMENT filename="BellSectioninCase.jpg" index="1">[attachment=1]BellSectioninCase.jpg</ATTACHMENT>

Note that this case has a more form fitting interior than the older Mt.Vernon cases. Also the round "Bach" badges on the outside. Older NY/MtVernon case:
<ATTACHMENT filename="CaseOpen.jpg" index="0">[attachment=0]CaseOpen.jpg</ATTACHMENT>

Later, they went to the square Dark brown cases with a medium brown trim (I don't have a picture of this). Some of these cases may be "Corporation" era horns, I have a 42 so marked and it was Original horn to the case. Similar colors to the Early Elkhart square case above.

Later still (late 80's? Early 90's?), the colors inverted, medium brown case with dark brown trim.

After that, you can see the current cases, more French style, still boxy.

Cheers,

Andy
M
Mamaposaune
Posts: 657
Joined: Sep 22, 2018

by Mamaposaune »

I would just like to add a few things to Andy's response

I think Bach dropped the "Corporation" and Elkhart IND bell inscription in the late 70's, possibly '80. That was around the same time they switched to the dark brown/lighter brown leather rectangular cases. (These cases were still pretty well made)

Sometime in the mid-80's, they went to a lighter brown case with dark brown vinyl at the ends. The quality was dropping. I think it was around the same time that Bach started offering the open-wrap option on the 36, 42, and 50. The cases were all the same, and could accommodate a straight horn, and either style of f-attachment.

They went back to dark brown, and around the mid-90's went to a case that is flat on one side, and an exaggerated bell flare on the other. The next one was the light brown fabric covered ones. (I think D.J. refers to them as "brownies") These were the cheapest cases of all, and the zippers and hinges did not hold up.

Finally, around 2015, Bach started using a respectable case again - one that more closely reflects the $$$ that they charge for their horns. I don't own one, but they look to be protective and durable, and fairly attractive. (I still like the old French cases best, though)
J
jacobgarchik
Posts: 358
Joined: Oct 27, 2018

by jacobgarchik »

I have two early 80s bachs, 1981 and 1982, both with the light brown cases.
J
JLivi
Posts: 870
Joined: May 10, 2018

by JLivi »

[quote="Mamaposaune"]Sometime in the mid-80's, they went to a lighter brown case with dark brown vinyl at the ends. The quality was dropping. I think it was around the same time that Bach started offering the open-wrap option on the 36, 42, and 50. The cases were all the same, and could accommodate a straight horn, and either style of f-attachment.[/quote]
Would you be hesitant to purchase a horn from that era? The Bach 36 in question appears to be from the early 90's based on the serial number. But it's also super cheap and an estate sale find. It's tough to pass up a 36b for $750.
M
Mamaposaune
Posts: 657
Joined: Sep 22, 2018

by Mamaposaune »

[quote="JLivi"]<QUOTE author="Mamaposaune" post_id="151420" time="1624381964" user_id="3765">
Sometime in the mid-80's, they went to a lighter brown case with dark brown vinyl at the ends. The quality was dropping. I think it was around the same time that Bach started offering the open-wrap option on the 36, 42, and 50. The cases were all the same, and could accommodate a straight horn, and either style of f-attachment.[/quote]
Would you be hesitant to purchase a horn from that era? The Bach 36 in question appears to be from the early 90's based on the serial number. But it's also super cheap and an estate sale find. It's tough to pass up a 36b for $750.
</QUOTE>

Not only would I not hesitate to buy one from the early 90's, I would probably prefer one from that era. I realize there are variations, but one of my favorite Bach's ever is my 42B that I bought new in '92. I've since replaced the case, though.

I cannot remember who said it, I think it was on this forum, that some of the best Bach's came from the early 90's. The brass they used was exceptionally good.

(It could have been someone associated with Baltimore Brass?)

Update: Todd Clontz was the source.
E
elmsandr
Posts: 1373
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by elmsandr »

(The parts are pretty good no matter the era)

Just for posterity;

80s/90s medium brown case (this one is later with the flat bottom. Helps it not teeter crazily when getting horn in and out of it.

<ATTACHMENT filename="2CC7BD80-23C0-4F1B-9B6B-054458A02845.jpeg" index="2">[attachment=2]2CC7BD80-23C0-4F1B-9B6B-054458A02845.jpeg</ATTACHMENT>

Late 90s early 00s zipper case. These suck.

<ATTACHMENT filename="5BC35D80-E4EE-4DF7-9C21-3F0A3FF31931.jpeg" index="1">[attachment=1]5BC35D80-E4EE-4DF7-9C21-3F0A3FF31931.jpeg</ATTACHMENT>

Current case. These look neat, I wouldn’t mind one, but people think they are worth money?!? I’ve got a half dozen of the old ones they can have…

<ATTACHMENT filename="9FC0DBF2-C733-486F-B133-80A407F4FC51.jpeg" index="0">[attachment=0]9FC0DBF2-C733-486F-B133-80A407F4FC51.jpeg</ATTACHMENT>

These pics sourced by eBay. Previous post are ones I own/ have owned.
D
djkennedy
Posts: 385
Joined: Apr 15, 2018

by djkennedy »

Number 313

Model 6

Case is

Molded pressed gray paper fiber

Covered in thin cotton cloth

With black paint

I call these TURTLE CASES

Because they look like snapping turtles

Slightly later shaped wood

And cofffin usually slide in lid

Leather snaps and leather covered handles

Latches hinges brass

Outstanding beautiful is a MV50

Gator fabric very open interior

40s cases are very good quality

And up through into Corp era

Nice to see current ones

THE BEST JAPANESE CASED BACH 42B

Viewed in stlouis at Doug Bert

While Gerry P was there we had lunch

Gerry enjoying CRISTAN ‘s latest mods to his axe
E
elmsandr
Posts: 1373
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by elmsandr »

[quote="djkennedy"]...

Outstanding beautiful is a MV50

Gator fabric very open interior

40s cases are very good quality

....[/quote]
<ATTACHMENT filename="Case.jpg" index="2">[attachment=2]Case.jpg</ATTACHMENT>
<ATTACHMENT filename="Horn in Case.jpg" index="1">[attachment=1]Horn in Case.jpg</ATTACHMENT>

...

THE BEST JAPANESE CASED BACH 42B

...

<ATTACHMENT filename="trombone12.jpg" index="0">[attachment=0]trombone12.jpg</ATTACHMENT>
S
spencercarran
Posts: 689
Joined: Oct 17, 2020

by spencercarran »

[quote="JLivi"]<QUOTE author="Mamaposaune" post_id="151420" time="1624381964" user_id="3765">
Sometime in the mid-80's, they went to a lighter brown case with dark brown vinyl at the ends. The quality was dropping. I think it was around the same time that Bach started offering the open-wrap option on the 36, 42, and 50. The cases were all the same, and could accommodate a straight horn, and either style of f-attachment.[/quote]
Would you be hesitant to purchase a horn from that era? The Bach 36 in question appears to be from the early 90's based on the serial number. But it's also super cheap and an estate sale find. It's tough to pass up a 36b for $750.
</QUOTE>
If you decide not to spring for that 36, let me know where it is please :good:
J
JLivi
Posts: 870
Joined: May 10, 2018

by JLivi »

[quote="spencercarran"]<QUOTE author="JLivi" post_id="151453" time="1624408915" user_id="3264">

Would you be hesitant to purchase a horn from that era? The Bach 36 in question appears to be from the early 90's based on the serial number. But it's also super cheap and an estate sale find. It's tough to pass up a 36b for $750.[/quote]
If you decide not to spring for that 36, let me know where it is please :good:
</QUOTE>
I see you’re in Chicago. I live in Arlington Heights. I’m going to buy it assuming they don’t have any other offers. If I don’t like it I’ll sell it to you for what I paid for it :-)