Large bore tenor opinions
- BflatBass
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Mar 23, 2018
I'm considering changing from my old King 3B to a larger tenor with an F valve so I'm looking for opinions on tenor trombones with a .547 bore (maybe .525) and an F attachment. If you have a favorite can you tell me what makes it better or worse than other similar horns that you've tried?
I haven't gone out to try anything yet but I just thought I'd see what people have to say so I can take that info with me as I give different horns a test run. Also I'm starting from scratch as my 3B is the only tenor I've owned since returning to the horn about a year ago.
Cheers,
Robert
I haven't gone out to try anything yet but I just thought I'd see what people have to say so I can take that info with me as I give different horns a test run. Also I'm starting from scratch as my 3B is the only tenor I've owned since returning to the horn about a year ago.
Cheers,
Robert
- harrisonreed
- Posts: 6479
- Joined: Aug 17, 2018
Get a used Edwards T350. Try to get a normal unsoldered yellow bell (as opposed to heavy) and a single radius rose tuning slide. The round Tenor Standard crook slide with normal yellow or rose brass tubes and a set of leadpipes will finish it off. That horn will take you far, and you can always tweak it later.
- Kingfan
- Posts: 1371
- Joined: Apr 11, 2018
If you like your 3B and your Duo Gravis, how about a King 4B-F? Me, I have a 2B, 3B, 3B-F, and 4B-F. I haven't played a lot of .547 horns, just my King since 1973, so can't really describe what makes it better or worse than the other horns like Conn 88H, Bach 42B, Blessing B-88, and the .547 Benges.
- BGuttman
- Posts: 7368
- Joined: Mar 22, 2018
If you like your 3B, you probably would like a King 4B. It's similar, only bigger. Generally a lighter horn; not as ponderous as a Bach 42. The original rotor is open enough that you don't need a fancy valve to get good response from the trigger side.
I also have spent a lot of time on a Yamaha 682G. Somewhere between the Bach and the King. Again, rotor is pretty open so you don't need a fancy valve.
If you are on a budget, look at the Yamaha 448 and Wessex Tubas horns.
I also have spent a lot of time on a Yamaha 682G. Somewhere between the Bach and the King. Again, rotor is pretty open so you don't need a fancy valve.
If you are on a budget, look at the Yamaha 448 and Wessex Tubas horns.
- walldaja
- Posts: 537
- Joined: Jul 11, 2018
Often you are limited by what is available in your local area. Try as many as you can and be willing to drive a bit in your search. Be prepared for a horn that will take a lot more air and use a large shank mouthpiece, that was my biggest take away when I went to a large bore. You may want to consider a .525 just to compare it to a .547 bore. Shires, Yamaha, and Antoine Courtois make some lower priced horns that are respectable. When you try the horns take notes--what you like, what you don't like, and your impressions. Try to record details of the horns like the type of wrap (open / closed) and crook design (squared / radius). Take time in your selection--the hunt is really the fun part.
- sacfxdx
- Posts: 406
- Joined: Apr 11, 2018
I would definitely check out the .525 bore horns. They are a good compromise. There are also .525 bore slide options for some of the .547 bore horns (88H). Lots of good used horns out there.
- Crazytrombonist505
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Mar 27, 2018
I have a Yamaha Xeno Ysl-882GO large bore tenor that I will be selling due to an upgrade. It’s a great player and is in great shape! PM me if you are interested.
- BflatBass
- Posts: 173
- Joined: Mar 23, 2018
[quote="BGuttman"]If you like your 3B, you probably would like a King 4B. It's similar, only bigger. Generally a lighter horn; not as ponderous as a Bach 42. The original rotor is open enough that you don't need a fancy valve to get good response from the trigger side.
I also have spent a lot of time on a Yamaha 682G. Somewhere between the Bach and the King. Again, rotor is pretty open so you don't need a fancy valve.
If you are on a budget, look at the Yamaha 448 and Wessex Tubas horns.[/quote]
The King 4B is a possibility as are many other horns. I'm not necessarily partial to Kings. Any brand will do as long as I like the feel and how I sound on it. I don't like the way I sound on my 3B just because it's too small. I like the feel and "playability" and sound I get on my Duo Gravis partially because it's a bigger horn. If I was primarily a lead player I'd keep the 3B and work more on my upper range but I don't play those parts much and so a bigger horn will feel more comfy and I would prefer a fuller, "bigger" sound. And since I'm playing lower parts more I'd like to have the F valve for convenience.
The Yamaha web site (usa.yamaha.com) doesn't list the 682 so I'm guessing it's an older model. Thanks for the input on these horns tho. I'll keep these things in mind when looking and testing.
I also have spent a lot of time on a Yamaha 682G. Somewhere between the Bach and the King. Again, rotor is pretty open so you don't need a fancy valve.
If you are on a budget, look at the Yamaha 448 and Wessex Tubas horns.[/quote]
The King 4B is a possibility as are many other horns. I'm not necessarily partial to Kings. Any brand will do as long as I like the feel and how I sound on it. I don't like the way I sound on my 3B just because it's too small. I like the feel and "playability" and sound I get on my Duo Gravis partially because it's a bigger horn. If I was primarily a lead player I'd keep the 3B and work more on my upper range but I don't play those parts much and so a bigger horn will feel more comfy and I would prefer a fuller, "bigger" sound. And since I'm playing lower parts more I'd like to have the F valve for convenience.
The Yamaha web site (usa.yamaha.com) doesn't list the 682 so I'm guessing it's an older model. Thanks for the input on these horns tho. I'll keep these things in mind when looking and testing.
- norbie2018
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Apr 05, 2018
A used Yamaha ysl-882 in either yellow or gold brass can be picked up used in good condition for around $1800, less if you shop around. Keep in mind it has a narrow Conn-style slide, in case that's an issue for you. That horn is a pro model instrument that'll last you the rest of your life.
- Bach5G
- Posts: 2874
- Joined: Apr 07, 2018
No better time to get a .547. Lots of choices, maybe too many.
- Kingfan
- Posts: 1371
- Joined: Apr 11, 2018
Check the classifieds on Trombone Chat. I see a Benge 165F and a Conn 88H. Which of these or any horns out there is right for you depends on your budget and which ones you like. There are variations even in the same horn. I was lucky to buy a nice 3B-F off eBay for a great price without trying it, but a mid-70s 3B is pretty much a slam dunk.