Mpc repair - how round can you get it?
- Bach5G
- Posts: 2874
- Joined: Apr 07, 2018
I received a mpc today - used - and the shank is an little out of round.
How much can you get back into round?
How much can you get back into round?
- Burgerbob
- Posts: 6327
- Joined: Apr 23, 2018
Totally depends. Sometimes you can't tell, sometimes it's never right again.
- ithinknot
- Posts: 1339
- Joined: Jul 24, 2020
You can get it pretty close to perfect, but not with just "the tool". The collars that Instrument Innovations sell are a good way for the band director to avoid overshooting and flaring the end, but if you're trying harder it's more a case of using loose mandrels and working the high spots from the outside.
If the backbore ends with a single taper, with a flat edge to the shank end, then you can usually get it very very close. It's harder to camouflage the exterior damage when there's an extra chamfer/countersink at the backbore exit.
The original damage is almost always repairable... other people's repair attempts, less so.
If the backbore ends with a single taper, with a flat edge to the shank end, then you can usually get it very very close. It's harder to camouflage the exterior damage when there's an extra chamfer/countersink at the backbore exit.
The original damage is almost always repairable... other people's repair attempts, less so.
- ghmerrill
- Posts: 2193
- Joined: Apr 02, 2018
^^^
This.
You have to remember that it's not a true cylinder you're dealing with. That makes it harder. And the chamfer/countersink issue may be ultimately insurmountable -- even with a lot more equipment than you're unlikely to see outside a real machine shop. Even then, ... :( I have one where I've decided "close enough is good enough".
This.
You have to remember that it's not a true cylinder you're dealing with. That makes it harder. And the chamfer/countersink issue may be ultimately insurmountable -- even with a lot more equipment than you're unlikely to see outside a real machine shop. Even then, ... :( I have one where I've decided "close enough is good enough".