Quick transposition question, Eb horn

T
timothy42b
Posts: 1812
Joined: Mar 27, 2018

by timothy42b »

I think I know the answer but I want to check before I do the work.

I need to transpose a Horn in F part for a player in our community band that can only read Horn in Eb.

I think that this just means that treble clef 3rd space C should sound Eb above middle C concert. So I just lower everything a whole step.

But I've got a nagging little thought I might be off an octave. She plays the horn parts on what seems to be an Eb alto horn rather than a French horn.
C
Chronos91
Posts: 64
Joined: Jul 10, 2022

by Chronos91 »

Horn in F parts sound a fifth lower than written. Eb alto horn parts sound a major sixth lower than written. If a treble clef C showed up in a part for horn in F, an Eb alto horn player would have to play a fourth line D for them. Basically, move everything up a major 2nd for the alto horn player. You'll also have to add two sharps.
H
harrisonreed
Posts: 6479
Joined: Aug 17, 2018

by harrisonreed »

Copy into your notation program for F horn, copy, then paste into a second instrument for Eb horn, then print the part. In this way, not only will the transposition be instantaneous, free of errors, and with accidentals that make sense, but the part will be clean as well
J
JohnL
Posts: 2529
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by JohnL »

[quote="harrisonreed"]Copy into your notation program for F horn, copy, then paste into a second instrument for Eb horn, then print the part. In this way, not only will the transposition be instantaneous, free of errors, and with accidentals that make sense, but the part will be clean as well[/quote]
What he said.

Musescore is open source (i.e., free), works well, and is pretty easy to learn.

If you MUST do it by hand, a written "C" on an F horn part translates to a written "D" on an Eb horn part; the instrument sounds a whole step lower, so the music is written a whole step higher. You'll also have to sort out the accidentals (add two sharps).
T
timothy42b
Posts: 1812
Joined: Mar 27, 2018

by timothy42b »

Thanks. I wanted to confirm there wasn't something I was missing.

I finished the first one, copying the Horn into F into notation, then using the transpose function to raise two half steps. The program caught all the key changes correctly.

This is kind of a pain in the butt, I'd forgotten how long it takes. I just have to crank through a couple more. The lesson is never volunteer. :biggrin: