Slide and valve wrap materiel matching

A
AAW
Posts: 4
Joined: Nov 18, 2025

by AAW »

Does having the slide outer material and the valve wrap material not match make the valve range sound different? I know that Edwards is a company that makes the materials match in most of their models, but is there a noticeable difference in sound in the valve range and the regular range when the slide and wrap material is different, compared to when they are the same?

All you are trying to do with a valve, in my opinion, is make it feel like the slide is 6 positions longer. Yes, the bore of the wrap is larger than the slide, and it is going through a valve, but does the added difference of material make the sound difference more noticeable?

I am just asking for any of your experiences, and any input would be nice.

Thanks.
B
Bonearzt
Posts: 833
Joined: Mar 22, 2018

by Bonearzt »

To quote a well-known Professional Trombonist & Teacher...

"The only thing that matters is everything"
S
sirisobhakya
Posts: 445
Joined: Jun 11, 2018

by sirisobhakya »

C on 6th position, on 1st with F valve, on 2nd with Gb valve, and on 3rd with both F and Gb valve feel and sound different even with same material used across the horn to begin with.