Case for dependent Thayers

F
fsgazda
Posts: 219
Joined: Jun 24, 2018

by fsgazda »

I just switched from in-line to dependent Thayer valves on my bass, and it won't fit in my BAM softpack case. Can anyone suggest a light, fairly safe case (like the BAM) that will fit this configuration:

http://w.hornguys.com/images/shiresstackedaxial.jpg

Thanks!

PS: There will be a BAM softpack on the market very soon................
T
TheBoneRanger
Posts: 225
Joined: Apr 04, 2018

by TheBoneRanger »

I had to sell my Bam a long time back for a similar reason.

I currently have a dependent Edwards in a Marcus Bonna, though many here suggest what I've been doing for a decade is impossible...

I also have a dependent Shires in a Protec Ipac, which I suspect would be roomy enough to swallow nearly any configuration.

Hope that helps,

Andrew
F
fsgazda
Posts: 219
Joined: Jun 24, 2018

by fsgazda »

[quote="TheBoneRanger"]I had to sell my Bam a long time back for a similar reason.

I currently have a dependent Edwards in a Marcus Bonna, though many here suggest what I've been doing for a decade is impossible...

I also have a dependent Shires in a Protec Ipac, which I suspect would be roomy enough to swallow nearly any configuration.

Hope that helps,

Andrew[/quote]

Hi,

Is the protec a soft case? It looks like it in the pictures that I found.

If it's not too much of a pain, could you post or send a pic of your horn in the Marcus Bonna?
N
norbie2018
Posts: 1051
Joined: Apr 05, 2018

by norbie2018 »

T
TheBoneRanger
Posts: 225
Joined: Apr 04, 2018

by TheBoneRanger »

[quote="fsgazda"]Is the protec a soft case? It looks like it in the pictures that I found.[/quote]

It's a similar construction to the Bonna, or at least a similar level of protection.

[quote="fsgazda"]If it's not too much of a pain, could you post or send a pic of your horn in the Marcus Bonna?[/quote]

User image

Andrew
S
Slideorama
Posts: 242
Joined: Jul 07, 2018

by Slideorama »

My dependent Edwards fits perfectly in my iPac case.

The thread title had my hopes up for an engaging chat or editorial about the use of or preference for dependent thayers.

<EMOJI seq="1f937-1f3fc-2642" tseq="1f937-1f3fc-200d-2642-fe0f">🤷🏼‍♂️</EMOJI>
F
fsgazda
Posts: 219
Joined: Jun 24, 2018

by fsgazda »

[quote="TheBoneRanger"]<QUOTE author="fsgazda" post_id="80679" time="1552696225" user_id="3435">
Is the protec a soft case? It looks like it in the pictures that I found.[/quote]

It's a similar construction to the Bonna, or at least a similar level of protection.

[quote="fsgazda"]If it's not too much of a pain, could you post or send a pic of your horn in the Marcus Bonna?[/quote]

User image

Andrew
</QUOTE>

Thanks. I have an email in to hornguys to see about the Modelo F case. It could be a trick of the angle, but I feel like my Shires is a little more offset (wider) than your Edwards. Probably not.
F
fsgazda
Posts: 219
Joined: Jun 24, 2018

by fsgazda »

[quote="Slideorama"]My dependent Edwards fits perfectly in my iPac case.

The thread title had my hopes up for an engaging chat or editorial about the use of or preference for dependent thayers.

<EMOJI seq="1f937-1f3fc-2642" tseq="1f937-1f3fc-200d-2642-fe0f">🤷🏼‍♂️</EMOJI>[/quote]

That's a whole other thread, but I will say that I am loving the new set up. Seems more stable. Even though I played in line since 1988 (!), I don't think that I'll miss too much about it.
M
MTbassbone
Posts: 558
Joined: Apr 21, 2018

by MTbassbone »

I also had my hopes for this being a Edwards dependent Thayer bass thread. I have played this horn for a few years now, and I recently almost traded it. I love how it plays, but it is a very heavy horn.
S
Slideorama
Posts: 242
Joined: Jul 07, 2018

by Slideorama »

Edwards dependent in the Protec iPac case

<ATTACHMENT filename="D8744B09-162F-4694-AAF8-4BDBB4E50FEA.jpeg" index="0">[attachment=0]D8744B09-162F-4694-AAF8-4BDBB4E50FEA.jpeg</ATTACHMENT>
F
fsgazda
Posts: 219
Joined: Jun 24, 2018

by fsgazda »

Just to follow up, I bought an XL Marcus Bonna from the hornguys. They thought that the wider (and deeper) bell area would allow the horn to sit lower in the case. It fits, and is lighter and slightly smaller than my BAM, so I'm happy all the way around.