Stuck DE shank

S
sf105
Posts: 433
Joined: Mar 24, 2018

by sf105 »

The shank is stuck on my DE mouthpiece. I'm hoping there's a cute trick to loosen it up rather than applying brute force. I've dripped a bit of oil in and I've tried (gently) heating the receiving cup. Neither worked.

Posting here so that the answer might be useful to others.

Thx
R
RichC
Posts: 177
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by RichC »

Gently tapping for a bit on the connection has worked for me.
P
pompatus
Posts: 434
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by pompatus »

[quote="Doug Elliott"]Loosening stuck mouthpiece parts:

You need a rawhide or wood mallet and a 9/16" box-end wrench for large shanks, or 1/2” for small shanks.  14mm and 13mm box-end wrenches will also work.

For the rim, one of two methods may work:

Tap around the top surface of the rim - sometimes that's all that's needed to loosen it.  If that doesn't work, hold the mouthpiece in your left hand with the rim facing away from you, and with the mallet hit the right edge of the rim downward with a glancing blow.  That puts force in the unscrewing direction.  Now turn the mouthpiece slightly and hit it again. Keep doing that until it loosens.  You might have to hit it pretty hard.  The wood or rawhide has enough friction to do the job but it won't hurt the plating.  Rubber mallets just bounce, plastic and anything harder can dent it.  Only use wood or rawhide.

For the shank, put the box end wrench on the hex.  Hit the opposite end of the wrench with the mallet, in the correct unscrewing direction. (Normal threads, turn left to loosen)

IMPACT, not brute force, is what works.

A little bit of Teflon tape on the threads will keep it from sticking.  Oil or grease doesn’t really help.
[/quote]

Doug addressed this in an old Trombone Forum post, here: https://www.trombonechat.com/viewtopic.php?t=462
H
harrisonreed
Posts: 6479
Joined: Aug 17, 2018

by harrisonreed »

The shank has a section near the threads that is shaped like a hexagonal nut. Get a rubber jar opener, put that on the cup, and put a wrench on the part of the shank that looks like it should accept a wrench (the nut part). Twist slowly and gently in opposite directions.

Use some sort of thick grease (I use chapstick) on the threads next time.
F
FullPedalTrombonist
Posts: 152
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by FullPedalTrombonist »

I used a wrench and belt it in place and twisted the cup by hand.

Doug’s advice is where I would go next if I couldn’t do it by hand.
T
TromboneMonkey
Posts: 271
Joined: May 11, 2018

by TromboneMonkey »

I always use a TheraBand and a wrench.

I'll be at ATW on Friday. I'll bring my TheraBand and charge $5 per loosen. :-D
S
sf105
Posts: 433
Joined: Mar 24, 2018

by sf105 »

reposting Doug's instructions. thanks all.

I've had so many questions about this that I decided to post instructions. I attached a PDF with these instruction plus pictures.

Loosening stuck mouthpiece parts:

You need a rawhide or wood mallet and a 9/16" box-end wrench for large shanks, or 1/2" for small shanks. 14mm and 13mm box-end wrenches will also work.

For the rim, one of two methods may work:

Tap around the top surface of the rim - sometimes that's all that's needed to loosen it. If that doesn't work, hold the mouthpiece in your left hand with the rim facing away from you, and with the mallet hit the right edge of the rim downward with a glancing blow. That puts force in the unscrewing direction. Now turn the mouthpiece slightly and hit it again. Keep doing that until it loosens. You might have to hit it pretty hard. The wood or rawhide has enough friction to do the job but it won't hurt the plating. Rubber mallets just bounce, plastic and anything harder can dent it. Only use wood or rawhide.

For the shank, put the box end wrench on the hex. Hit the opposite end of the wrench with the mallet, in the correct unscrewing direction. (Normal threads, turn left to loosen)

IMPACT, not brute force, is what works.

A little bit of Teflon tape on the threads will keep it from sticking. Oil or grease doesn't really help.
J
jimtheob
Posts: 35
Joined: Mar 27, 2018

by jimtheob »

Doug's instructions work perfectly.