Older bach mouthpieces vs new ones

S
Slydeflex
Posts: 41
Joined: Apr 16, 2020

by Slydeflex »

Has anyone noticed any difference playing wise between older and newer bach mouthpieces? I have a 70's era and a newer one and prefer the newer.
B
Burgerbob
Posts: 6327
Joined: Apr 23, 2018

by Burgerbob »

There's a difference between basically every mouthpiece made by Bach (or any maker, really).

In general? Some are bigger now. Some by a lot (3G). Otherwise I'm not sure if you can much of anything that would be wholly encompassing.
T
Thrawn22
Posts: 1436
Joined: Sep 06, 2018

by Thrawn22 »

Burgerbob has it pretty spot on. Some makers are more consistent but older (especially Bach) have the reputation of being all over the road, thus feel and play differently. I have several Bach 7 mouthpieces ( couple Mt.Vernon, a couple of corp., a newer one) and they all are a bit different. I have a Mt.Vernon that feels a bit smaller than the Mt.Vernon, and the larger fo those 2 is pretty close to a Corp. lettered i have.

A story i heard about Roy Main is in the first lesson or so with him he would open a drawer full of Bach 11c mouthpieces and would have you try out each one till he heard one that sounded good and would tell you to keep it and bring $36 to tbe next lesson.
S
Slydeflex
Posts: 41
Joined: Apr 16, 2020

by Slydeflex »

[quote="Thrawn22"]

A story i heard about Roy Main is in the first lesson or so with him he would open a drawer full of Bach 11c mouthpieces and would have you try out each one till he heard one that sounded good and would tell you to keep it and bring $36 to tbe next lesson.[/quote]

That is interesting, my experience so far has been that the newer bachs are tighter, more focused than some older ones
B
bassbone721
Posts: 45
Joined: Jan 17, 2020

by bassbone721 »

On my 3b, I have a corp. 6 1/2 al and a new 6 1/2 and the corp is slightly darker, but the newer is slightly more easy to play.
S
Slydeflex
Posts: 41
Joined: Apr 16, 2020

by Slydeflex »

[quote="bassbone721"]On my 3b, I have a corp. 6 1/2 al and a new 6 1/2 and the corp is slightly darker, but the newer is slightly more easy to play.[/quote]

That is what i found also.
G
GabrielRice
Posts: 1496
Joined: Mar 23, 2018

by GabrielRice »

The quick answer to any question about comparing Bach mouthpieces is: they're different.

Got two you bought on the same day? They're different.

And it's not just Bach. I have never found two mouthpieces of the same model from any manufacturer that were identical.
V
Vegasbound
Posts: 1328
Joined: Jul 06, 2019

by Vegasbound »

Just find the one you like and practice
D
djkennedy
Posts: 385
Joined: Apr 15, 2018

by djkennedy »

There is the time

Bubble Bill Hamilton

Went on the road w Doug Elliot

In a MOOD band

Bill had been trying to play 11C for years

Because of Jangles and Carl

Ok 4 rim w a Cish cup
B
Basbasun
Posts: 496
Joined: Mar 26, 2018

by Basbasun »

The old ones are more expencive.
L
Leanit
Posts: 160
Joined: Sep 04, 2018

by Leanit »

For some reason I've always liked the MV era better. I'm not sure whether they are, or perhaps it's just sentimentality for something old. That said, the New York pieces don't suit me.

The only consistent aspect is inconsistency.